Source: Pann

I noticed some followers saying that Suga is BTS’ important producer and that BTS can’t launch songs with out him as a result of he produces BTS’ songs. I’m actually sorry however I’ve to deliver up RM in some elements. If we’re going to speak about Suga by way of producing, we’ve to speak about RM as nicely.

Firstly, have a look at this image. There’s no detailed details about album composers on Namuwiki and the Korean Wikipedia, so I’ve to add it in English. 

Song credit enhance based mostly on contribution. The important producer or important composer/lyricist’s identify all the time comes first. The different contributors? We haven’t any manner of understanding how a lot they really take part. We can solely guess.

Below are BTS’ track composers and producers. I didn’t add Japanese albums, however Japanese credit aren’t completely different from Korean album credit. The important producer is all the time Pdogg.

Pdogg’s identify = yellow, Suga’s identify = purple

– Out of all of BTS’ songs, Suga is the principle producer for under 4 songs: “Let Me Know” “Interlude: Shadow” “Tomorrow “Jump”
– Out of all BTS’ songs, Suga solely participated in producing 3 songs: “First Love” “Respect” “Skit”
– Suga is the principle lyricist for under 3 songs: I”nterlude: Shadow” “Tomorrow” “Jump”
– Pdogg alone is just producer for all of BTS’s important profitable songs
– All of BTS’s profitable songs had been additionally made by Pdogg alone

KOMCA broadcasts the highest 10 earners in royalties yearly. Pdogg and Bang Si Hyuk took 1st place in 2019, 2020, 2021, and 2022.
This is the record of 2022 

So now let’s test this,

-Idols with probably the most copyrights in 2022:
#2 BTS RM (187 songs)
#4 GD (174 songs)
#9 Suga (134 songs)
#37 IU (72 songs)

-Melon Streams in 2022:
#1 BTS — 12,417,055,600 streams (267 songs)
#3 IU — 7,716,769,400 streams (122 songs)
#5 BIGBANG — 3,159,735,800 streams (68 songs)
(GD was not within the high 100)

But?????
-People with probably the most copyright revenue in 2022:
#6 GD
#8 IU

Then why are RM and Suga not on this record??
Have you ever thought of why RM has extra copyrights than IU and GD, and people copyrighted songs had been streamed 3-4 instances greater than IU and GD’s, and bought 6 million instances extra albums in 2022, however they don’t seem to be within the high 10 in copyright revenue? Isn’t that bizarre?

Post interplay: +824, -92

1. [+467, -10] I actually don’t perceive why Suga himself and Armys suppose that he writes genius lyrics, truthfully his lyrics suck… How many instances are they going to name him genius? Even Mozart himself by no means pulled this kind of bulls**t ㅋㅋㅋㅋ 

“I’m so thankful, I’m a genius, That’s your reason for using drugs, cry me a river, you just got no skills”

2. [+223, -8] Suga isn’t good at composing or producing. Do you keep in mind Suga’s track ‘What Do You Think’? That track was claimed to be a self-produced solng, however when the Jim Jones controversy arose, HYBE shortly added one other producer and songwriter to the credit, they usually clarified that the controversial elements had been made by the opposite producer, not Suga.

3.[+156, -17] It’s as a result of he hardly ever performs a job in singing. He’s not able to be known as as BTS’ producer as nicely. BTS wouldn’t lose their coloration with out him

4. [+124, -11] Honestly, nothing would change if until Pdogg leaves the corporate. They additionally acquired songs from a variety of exterior producers, and similar to the submit says, I additionally don’t suppose he’s that nice of a producer himself ㅋㅋㅋ…

5. [+114, -5] Credits for a track enhance based mostly on contribution, so in the event you’re not the principle, your contribution is perhaps lower than 1%. It is perhaps nearly nothing. It’s not stunning that nowadays idols have 10 or so important composers and solely record their names in credit, proper? You can get credit score simply by arising with an concept or altering a phrase. If Suga doesn’t earn cash from track royalties, it means there an issue with contribution. But I agree with what you mentioned about advertising technique. I do know he has a lot of self-composed songs, however I don’t know if he correctly wrote a couple of strains of lyrics for songs that had been standard ㅋㅋㅋ

6.[+85 -40] The group is standard, so that they needed to put him in composer line-up in order that he wouldn’t appear to have no position in group

“Someone said it’s famous. I don’t know why it’s famous but it’s just famous!”

7.[+75, -4] A genius kickboard attraction

8.[+70, -7] Putting apart the truth that he’s unhealthy at producing or writing lyrics, every time I see him now, all I can consider is that this and that shit and it’s so funnyㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ

9.[+69, -32] He’s not even Jungkook, and he mentioned he’s worldwide so I used to be like, “Huh??” He doesn’t sing or rap that nicely

10.[+54, -3] It’s all the time humorous to see HYBE put “(Produced by BTS Suga)” in each track of singers he produced or participated within the manufacturing no less than somewhat bit ㅋㅋ There are so many singers who make songs for different individuals, however that is the primary time I’ve seen somebody who’s so determined to indicate off like them..The just one who wrote “Produced by so-and-so” subsequent to a track was Mnet’s who wrote Zico’s identify however he has a variety of hit songs and Mnet needed to brag that the “Produce 101” group’s track was produced by Zico.. Conclusion:  Suga can produce, sure, however his share inside BTS is totally not as HYBE promotes him, and is the truth is minimal.